‘That this House have no confidence in Dr Philip Giddings as Chair of this House.’
Results
| In Favour | Against |
| 47 | 80 |
Thirteen abstentions were recorded.
The motion was lost after a division of the House.
The contents of this web page have been extracted from this file on the Church of England website. I have re-arranged them by synod number (which brings members together by diocese), and added absentees and vacancies. For this purpose an “absentee” is someone who did not record an electronic vote (for/against/abstention). There are various reasons for being an absentee (eg not being able to take the day off work). In addition some at least of the three ecclesiastical judges consider it inappropriate to vote on church legislation which they may later have to enforce.
Peter Owen
| House of Laity – 18 January 2013 | ||||
| Diocese etc | Surname | synod no | Vote | |
| Bath & Wells | Armitstead | Edward | 244 | Against |
| Hind | Timothy | 245 | absent | |
| Humphreys | Jennifer | 246 | For | |
| Stobart | Cherida | 247 | absent | |
| Wilson-Rudd | Fay | 248 | Against | |
| Birmingham | Gooder | Paula | 249 | absent |
| Holgate | Robert | 250 | For | |
| Jepson | Rachel | 251 | For | |
| Blackburn | Burrows | Gerald | 252 | Against |
| Goddard | Vivienne | 253 | Against | |
| Leathard | Helen | 254 | absent | |
| Lyon | Rosemary | 255 | Against | |
| Witts | Susan | 256 | absent | |
| Wynne | Alison | 257 | Against | |
| Bradford | Fletcher | Ian | 258 | absent |
| Halliday | Malcolm | 259 | For | |
| Mallard | Zahida | 260 | Against | |
| Bristol | Froude | David | 261 | absent |
| Harrison | Glynn | 262 | Against | |
| Yemm | Ian | 263 | absent | |
| Canterbury | Kemp | David | 264 | For |
| Muggeridge | Sally | 265 | absent | |
| Spencer | Caroline | 266 | For | |
| Carlisle | Angus | Christopher | 267 | abstain |
| Hanson | Charles | 268 | Against | |
| Hine | Geoffrey | 269 | For | |
| Mills | David | 270 | Against | |
| Chelmsford | Adcock | Isabel | 271 | absent |
| Durlacher | Mary | 272 | Against | |
| Hammond | Robert | 273 | For | |
| Morgan | David | 274 | Against | |
| Playle | Kathleen | 275 | Against | |
| Stevens | Robin | 276 | abstain | |
| Whitworth | Ruth | 277 | Against | |
| Chester | Berry | Anthony | 278 | absent |
| Campbell | Graham | 279 | Against | |
| Dunlop | Jennifer | 280 | absent | |
| Freeman | John | 281 | For | |
| Hart | Peter | 282 | Against | |
| Haslam | Lois | 283 | absent | |
| Mason | John | 284 | abstain | |
| Renshaw | Elizabeth | 285 | absent | |
| Chichester | Ashwin | John | 286 | absent |
| Ashworth | Lorna | 287 | Against | |
| Booth | John | 288 | Against | |
| Brett | Justin | 289 | absent | |
| Gilliver | Joy | 290 | Against | |
| Nagel | Mary | 291 | Against | |
| Vince | Jacob | 292 | absent | |
| Minichiello Williams | Andrea | 293 | Against | |
| Coventry | Dyer | Kay | 294 | absent |
| Margrave | Samuel | 295 | Against | |
| Warren | Yvonne | 296 | absent | |
| Derby | Collard | Peter | 297 | absent |
| Goddard | Madelaine | 298 | For | |
| McMullen | Christine | 299 | absent | |
| Durham | Goudie | Angus | 300 | abstain |
| Harrison | Jamie | 301 | absent | |
| Williams | Anne | 302 | Against | |
| Wood | Frances | 303 | For | |
| Ely | Perrett | Janet | 304 | For |
| Storkey | Elaine | 305 | For | |
| Tooke | Stephen | 306 | For | |
| Europe | Ratcliffe Holmes | Madeleine | 307 | For |
| Turner | Ann | 308 | Against | |
| Exeter | Barrell | Anneliese | 309 | Against |
| Foreman | Anne | 310 | For | |
| Forward | Emma | 311 | Against | |
| Hodgson | Charles | 312 | For | |
| Shelley | Jack | 313 | abstain | |
| Gloucester | Belcher | William | 314 | Against |
| Smith | Graham | 315 | absent | |
| Tann | Jennifer | 316 | absent | |
| Guildford | Bruinvels | Peter | 317 | Against |
| Malcouronne | Keith | 318 | Against | |
| Martin | Anne | 319 | absent | |
| Vincent | Adrian | 320 | Against | |
| Hereford | Dinnen | John | 321 | For |
| Elcock | Martin | 322 | absent | |
| Lording | Rosemary | 323 | absent | |
| Leicester | Ardron | Shayne | 324 | abstain |
| Barney | Stephen | 325 | For | |
| Bloor | Anne | 326 | Against | |
| Lichfield | Allen | Penelope | 327 | For |
| Beswick | David | 328 | Against | |
| Corbet | Christopher | 329 | Against | |
| Monckton | Joanna | 330 | Against | |
| Shand | John | 331 | absent | |
| Tan | Chik Kaw | 332 | Against | |
| Wilson | John | 333 | Against | |
| Lincoln | Beck | Rachel | 334 | For |
| Pounds | Sylvia | 335 | absent | |
| Slater | Sue | 336 | For | |
| Ticehurst | Carol | 337 | Against | |
| Liverpool | Hancock | Paul | 338 | For |
| Pye | Christopher | 339 | Against | |
| Stafford | Mark | 340 | For | |
| Swinson | Margaret | 341 | abstain | |
| Walker | Debrah | 342 | absent | |
| London | Cooper | Susan | 343 | absent |
| Finch | Sarah | 344 | Against | |
| Hargreaves-Smith | Aiden | 345 | Against | |
| Johnston | Mary | 346 | For | |
| Newcombe | Lindsay | 347 | Against | |
| Rice | Philip | 348 | Against | |
| Roy | Anirban | 349 | abstain | |
| Ruoff | Alison | 350 | Against | |
| Scowen | Clive | 351 | Against | |
| Ward | John | 352 | For | |
| Manchester | Barber | John | 353 | Against |
| Capon | Peter | 354 | Against | |
| Heppleston | Michael | 355 | Against | |
| Blinkhorn | Phillip | 356 | For | |
| Tattersall | Geoffrey | 357 | absent | |
| Townsend | James | 358 | For | |
| Newcastle | Bull | John | 359 | For |
| White | Margaret | 360 | Against | |
| Wolstenholme | Carol | 361 | absent | |
| Norwich | Back | Robin | 362 | absent |
| Johns | Sue | 363 | absent | |
| Wortley | Geoffrey | 364 | absent | |
| Oxford | Dailey | Prudence | 365 | Against |
| Dziegiel | Julie | 366 | Against | |
| Giddings | Philip | 367 | Against | |
| Hurley | Robert | 368 | Against | |
| Newey | Brian | 369 | absent | |
| Oldham | Gavin | 370 | For | |
| Russell | Victoria | 371 | Against | |
| Thomas-Betts | Anna | 372 | For | |
| Peterborough | Allsopp | Dennis | 373 | absent |
| Heald | Veronica | 374 | Against | |
| Presland | Andrew | 375 | Against | |
| Portsmouth | Docherty | Lucy | 376 | absent |
| Sutton | Debbie | 377 | absent | |
| Sutton | Debbie | 378 | For | |
| Ripon & Leeds | Beal | John | 379 | Against |
| Greenwood | Nigel | 380 | For | |
| Mantle | Richard | 381 | Against | |
| Rochester | Cheeseman | James | 382 | Against |
| Dobbie | Ian | 383 | Against | |
| French | Philip | 384 | For | |
| O'Brien | Gerald | 385 | Against | |
| Scott | Angela | 386 | Against | |
| St Albans | Baynes | Simon | 387 | For |
| Follett | Samuel | 388 | absent | |
| Marshall | Edmund | 389 | For | |
| McDonough | Philip | 390 | absent | |
| Rees | Christina | 391 | For | |
| Seddon | William | 392 | absent | |
| St E & I | Allen | Timothy | 393 | For |
| Condick | Margaret | 394 | For | |
| Smith | Peter | 395 | absent | |
| Salisbury | Boyd-Lee | Paul | 396 | Against |
| Bromilow | Ian | 397 | absent | |
| Corteen | Christine | 398 | absent | |
| Fielden | Christopher | 399 | absent | |
| Key | Robert | 400 | For | |
| McIsaac | Debrah | 401 | abstain | |
| Sheffield | Butcher | Jacqueline | 402 | absent |
| Patterson | Janet | 403 | absent | |
| Paver | Elizabeth | 404 | Against | |
| Sodor & Man | Davenport | Laura | 405 | absent |
| Southwark | Alexander | April | 406 | For |
| Gnanadoss | Vasantha | 407 | Against | |
| Greenwood | Adrian | 408 | Against | |
| Haddock | Peter | 409 | Against | |
| Hall | Robin | 410 | For | |
| Sutcliffe | Thomas | 411 | Against | |
| Wilson | Brian | 412 | absent | |
| Southwell & Nott | Bishop | Pamela | 413 | For |
| Harding | Nicholas | 414 | For | |
| Slater | Colin | 415 | For | |
| Truro | Leafe | Susannah | 416 | Against |
| Sturgess | Sheridan | 417 | Against | |
| Terrett | Paul | 418 | absent | |
| Wakefield | Ashton | David | 419 | abstain |
| Fisher | Alison | 420 | For | |
| Judkins | Mary | 421 | Against | |
| Neville | Paul | 422 | Against | |
| Winchester | Bennett | Anthony | 423 | absent |
| Davies | John | 424 | Against | |
| Fry | Christine | 425 | Against | |
| Shorey | Kenneth | 426 | Against | |
| Hungerford | Priscilla | 427 | Against | |
| Bisson | Janet | 428 | absent | |
| Robilliard | David | 429 | Against | |
| Worcester | Barton | Jennifer | 430 | absent |
| Clarke | Michael | 431 | absent | |
| Lunn | Robin | 432 | absent | |
| York | Ali | Linda | 433 | abstain |
| Brewer | Rosalind | 434 | absent | |
| Brewer | Rosalind | 434 | Against | |
| Dales | Martin | 436 | Against | |
| Reid | Jennifer | 437 | absent | |
| Steel | Jon | 438 | absent | |
| Services | Sargent | Philippa | 443 | absent |
| McAllister | Peter | 444 | absent | |
| Hayler | Lynn | 445 | absent | |
| Religious Communities | Quin OSB | Thomas | 448 | absent |
| Smith OHP | Anita | 449 | For | |
| ex officio | George | Charles | 456 | absent |
| Briden | Timothy | 457 | abstain | |
| Collier | Peter | 458 | absent | |
| Whittam Smith | Andreas | 459 | absent | |
| Baldry MP | Tony | 460 | absent | |
| vacancy | 461 | |||
| Spencer | Jonathan | 462 | absent | |
| Britton | Andrew | 464 | Against | |
| Chapman | Mary | 465 | abstain | |
| Craven | John | 466 | absent | |
| Fletcher | Philip | 467 | Against | |
| Swinson | Rebecca | 469 | absent | |
| For | 47 | |||
| Against | 80 | |||
| abstain | 13 | |||
| absent | 71 | |||